Skip to main content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.
Home

TUNI 101: Honors Education: Theory, Research, & Practice: Scholarly Journals

Characteristics of scholarly journals

Sources for finding scholarly publications

Is this SCHOLARLY material?

Comparing Scholarly Journals, Magazines, and Trade Journals

 

 

Scholarly Journals

 

Magazines

 

Trade Journals

Advertising

Minimal to none

Significant

Significant

Audience

Students, experts and subject specialists; language used by experts in the field

Consumers or general public; language is meant for a broad audience

Practitioners; those who work in the field; language specific to the profession

Authors

Identified with contact information; expertise identified

May or may not be identified

Typically identified with indication of expertise

Content

Often, standardized sections such as Literature Review, Methodology, Discussion, Conclusion; may be 10-20 pages or more

Typically short articles; may be less than one page

Varies in format, although there may be standard columns in each issue or standard formats

Cover appearance

Plain and consistent appearance; may include Table of Contents; typically will provide volume and other numbers or dates

Glossy covers; photographs; other cover art. 

Photographs or art work specific to the field

Graphics

Tables, figures, or graphs are most typical

Full range of graphic art and photography

Mix of business or scholarly graphics and other artwork

Peer reviewed

Look at the journals’ “Instructions for authors.”  May be peer reviewed by a panel of experts. 

No

Sometimes

 

Purpose

To report original research or promote critical discussion of a topic

To entertain, inform

To inform practitioners in a field

Titles

May include Advances in, American, Annual, Journal of, Research, Review, Transactions, International

Popular titles, consumer-oriented

Identifies the trade or profession in some way

Examples

 

Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology

 

Research in Higher Education

Saturday Evening Post

 

Consumer Reports

Food Business News

 

American Libraries